Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Too Much Pressure

"Mommy," Alexander approached me with the plaintive voice that means something is bothering him. "I need to decide what I want to be when I grow up." The enormity of this task was clearly weighing on him.
If you had asked Alexander at age 4 what he wanted to be when he grew up, he would
have rattled off a list of about 5 things, mostly consisting of the
usual little-boy fantasy careers: dump truck driver, fire fighter, rock
star. But now that he's seven, he knows that his options are wide open
and he has plenty of time in the future to explore what jobs he might be right for him. If you ask him now, his answer is a very age-appropriate "I don't know."

I knew right away where this was coming from. This weekend, Alexander broke his pinky finger. The break was close enough to his knuckle that the urgent care doctor wanted him to see a hand specialist to make sure it didn't require any extraordinary measures. (It didn't.) Firmin took him to the hand doctor on Monday. When they came back, Firmin told me about how the doctor seemed to have a bit of a fixation on Alexander's future career choice. Asking a kid what he wants to be when he grows up is standard doctor small-talk, but this guy seemed to have a hard time taking "I don't know" for an answer. "He kept coming back to it", Firmin observed. We found this strange and mildly annoying, but didn't give it much more thought.

Alexander, on the other hand, apparently took it much more seriously. He told me the doctor said he had "two weeks to think about it" and he's going to ask again when we go back for the 2 week check. (why???) Xan is all stressed about this. Sigh. All my good mom advice about ignoring such rude behavior from the doctor, and how much time he has, blah, blah blah, is falling on deaf ears. He wants to have an answer, but he doesn't want to just make something up. "I don't want to tell him a lie!" Ah, my sweet, sweet, child! How can I argue with that? So we did a little brainstorming this evening. He was surprised to realize that there are real jobs with the Lego company. He found that intriguing. (We even looked up some vacancies -- many in Denmark!) "Video game designer" was another possibility. He laughed at my suggestion of saying he was going to be a bum and never leave home, but he won't really say that, of course. I secretly wish he would. I'd love to see the look on the doctor's face when I backed that statement up with a proud, beaming smile.

The larger issue here is why do some adults think it's cute to put kids on the spot like this? A *7* year old must have a specific career ambition? Does he really think that or is he simply unable to see when he's making his patients uncomfortable with his clueless banter? Does he badger his adult patients about stuff they'd rather not talk about? (I doubt it, though I've met one or two doctors who are socially inept enough to come close.) Why do adults do this? This doctor is not the only example we've experienced of otherwise nice grown-ups treating children like this. They repeatedly ask questions the child is clearly uncomfortable answering, or they insist that the child try or do something they clearly don't care to try or do. I'm not talking about things that the child should or must do for a good reason, such as saying "ah" so that the doctor can look at an infected throat. I'm talking about nagging a shy child to show off for a group, or quizzing a child (not their own) on something they are studying in school, even after it becomes clear they don't enjoy the quiz. I'm talking about insisting that a 7 year old decide on a future career in only 2 weeks and expecting him to realize it's a joke, except it's not really a joke because he knows you won't lay off until he gives a convincing answer.

4 comments:

Jodi said...

My goodness - I'm still not sure what I want to be when I grow up. :)

Jan Lyn said...

I'll second what Jodi just wrote! :) I seriously think adults need to respect children so much more and let them speak as led. I also have had my children "quizzed" by others after we began homeschooling. Some children are out-going and thrive on that sort of interaction, but I think most feel like the majority of adults would: pressured and on the spot.

Just Me said...

I hope Alexander doesn't spend too much time worrying about answering the question. Situations like that are frustrating and I never know how to handle them.

My one son will always say something like "I've got some ideas I'm trying out and I've got plenty of time to decide". Funny thing is, he has for sometime now said he wants to be a vet. He just doesn't like strangers asking him a question like that so he always gives that answer. The adults usually respond with agreement that he does have time to decide and the conversation is over.

It seems that our culture wants children to be mini adults now from ever earlier ages. We just finished a soccer season where I heard a comment from a parent about needing to get their 3 year old into the right soccer camp and onto the team with the right coach because if they didn't their child would not have a chance of reaching his full potential as a soccer player. There was no mention of fun or even if the child likes soccer or questioning that 3 seemed awfully early for this kind of pressure. It was all about the adult and the idea of having a child prodigy they could brag about. I was left speechless.

There is a great book called Under Pressure that draws attention to this phenomenon and the way children's lives have been taken over by their parents and society at large (from education to organized sports to birthday parties).

huddtoo said...

Very interesting!

Just me...your response to the question Stephanie's A is pondering ("I've got some ideas I'm trying out and I've got plenty of time to decide") is great!!
And..on the soccer thing. I agree. My daughter (9) plays and she has had the same coach for 3 years, his daughter is a good player, although she is now getting to rough, bossy and cocky. I see in her what you explain. With only like 3 weeks left in the season, he decided to add her to a U12 team (we are U10 age group)...so she had to then practice AND play for 2 teams, and the U12 girls didn't really want to welcome her with open arms. Not good, but I don't blame them...what is this little girl (she's small for her age) doing joining a team who's worked all year and bonded with only a few weeks left? It's HER DAD! He thinks he has some soccer prodigy on his hands. I was so irked when I saw her practicing with her new U12 team at the same time as her U10 team, then she comes over after they are done and he was going to put her in a scrimmage and pull another girl out. WHAT? She didn't practice with her team, yet you want to pull a girl dedicated to U10 team out for her? Just sad.

Whew...rant! :)

Stephanie, I work in a hosp, so I know first hand how many docs are so smart they have NO common sense! And I wonder if they feel (or any adult really) to ask the "what do you want to be when you grow up" question because it seems to be something that has been asked forever. I remember that when I was young. But, thinking back, I think the adults were curious as to what may be going thru a little kids head, what do they think would be exciting. Do they think MY job would be exciting? Maybe they are looking for an idea (the grownup..LOL). I don't see the question as bad, but I do see the badgering as bad, and certainly should not have told A that he wants an answer in 2 weeks, that *is* to much, esp when he does not know your child at all. A lot of times, esp in A's situation at the time, it's asked because they don't know what else to ask and they are trying to distract the child. He could have asked about hobbies, esp considering A's age. But, then the doc wouldn't want to feel silly if he didn't know what bakugan's are or what XYZ video game is all about. You know what I mean.

Sorry so long!! :)